| NAME | YEAR | SPORT | TEAM | POSITION/EVENT |
| LUIS DE LA CRUZ | 2023 | BASEBALL | SECOND TEAM | CATCHER |
| KADEN STEVENS | 2023 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST TEAM (NATIONAL CHAMPION) | TRIPLE JUMP |
| KADEN STEVENS | 2023 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND TEAM (RUNNER-UP) | LONG JUMP |
| KADEN STEVENS | 2022 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND TEAM (RUNNER-UP) | TRIPLE JUMP |
| KADEN STEVENS | 2022 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND TEAM (RUNNER-UP) | 400 METER HURDLES |
| TAMIR WILLIAMS | 2022 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | THIRD PLACE | LONG JUMP |
| JORGE DUTAN | 2019 | MEN’S CROSS COUNTRY | HONORABLE MENTION | 14TH PLACE |
| ALLISON BRYAN | 2019 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST TEAM (NATIONAL CHAMPION) | NJCAA NATIONALS/HEPTATHALON |
| JUSTINE CONCA | 2018 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST TEAM (NATIONAL CHAMPION) | NJCAA NATIONALS/STEEPLECHASE |
| JUSTINE CONCA | 2018 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | COACHES ALL-AMERICAN (THIRD PLACE) | NJCAA NATIONALS/1,500M |
| JUSTINE CONCA | 2018 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | COACHES ALL-AMERICAN (THIRD PLACE) | NJCAA NATIONALS/10,000M |
| ALLISON BRYAN | 2018 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST TEAM (NATIONAL CHAMPION) | NJCAA NATIONALS/HEPTATHALON |
| ALLISON BRYAN | 2018 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | COACHES ALL-AMERICAN (THIRD PLACE) | NJCAA NATIONALS/HIGH JUMP |
| ELIZABETH VARGAS | 2018 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST TEAM (NATIONAL CHAMPION) | NJCAA NATIONALS/JAVELIN |
| ROLAND GAMEZ | 2018 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND TEAM | NJCAA NATIONALS/DECATHLON |
| ROLAND GAMEZ | 2018 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND TEAM | NJCAA NATIONALS/110M HURDLES |
| MUHAMMAD OMBALI | 2018 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | COACHES ALL-AMERICAN (THIRD PLACE) | NJCAA NATIONALS/110M HURDLES |
| CHRISTOPHER BENITEZ | 2018 | MEN’S CROSS COUNTRY | HONORABLE MENTION | 15TH PLACE |
| CAMILLE CALUPAD | 2017 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST TEAM (NATIONAL CHAMPION) | NJCAA NATIONALS/POLE VAULT |
| CONNOR BEST | 2017 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND TEAM | NJCAA NATIONALS/DISCUS |
| JUSTINE CONCA | 2016 | WOMEN’S CROSS COUNTRY | Fourth Place | NJCAA NATIONALS |
| JUSTINE CONCA | 2016 | WOMEN’S CROSS COUNTRY | Women’s Athlete of the Year | EAST REGION |
| GARRETT PYNN | 2016 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIELD ATHLETE OF THE MEET | EAST REGION |
| GARRETT PYNN | 2016 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST TEAM (NATIONAL CHAMPION) | DISCUS |
| GARRETT PYNN | 2016 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | COACHES ALL-AMERICAN (THIRD PLACE) | SHOT PUT |
| TYLER OLIVIERI | 2016 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | COACHES ALL-AMERICAN (THIRD PLACE) | HIGH JUMP |
| AMANDA DURAN | 2016 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | EIGHTH PLACE | 5000 METER RUN |
| CONNOR MCGILLICK | 2016 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | EIGHTH PLACE | 5000 METER RUN |
| MALIK STEWART | 2015 | MEN’S SOCCER | SECOND TEAM | FORWARD |
| JUNIOR NASI | 2015 | BASEBALL | SECOND TEAM | SHORTSTOP |
| GARRET PYNN | 2015 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | COACHES ALL-AMERICAN (THIRD PLACE) | SHOT PUT |
| GERARD LONDINO | 2015 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | COACHES ALL-AMERICAN (THIRD PLACE) | JAVELIN |
| DEREK JOSELEN | 2015 | Men’s TRACK & FIELD | SIXTH PLACE | 200 Meters |
| ALEXANDRA RAFFA | 2015 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SHOT PUT | |
| KEVIN CAMPOS | 2014 | MEN’S SOCCER | SECOND TEAM | FORWARD |
| ERIC SAPIRO | 2014 | MEN’S TENNIS | SECOND TEAM | SECOND DOUBLES |
| KYLE FLIGEL | 2014 | MEN’S TENNIS | SECOND TEAM | SECOND DOUBLES |
| EZIO CECERE | 2014 | MEN’S TENNIS | SECOND TEAM | FOURTH SINGLES |
| DAVID SELT | 2014 | MEN’S TENNIS | SECOND TEAM | SECOND SINGLES |
| ERIC SAPIRO | 2013 | MEN’S TENNIS | FIRST TEAM | THIRD DOUBLES |
| DAN WINTERS | 2013 | MEN’S TENNIS | FIRST TEAM | THIRD DOUBLES |
| EZIO CECERE | 2013 | MEN’S TENNIS | SECOND TEAM | SECOND DOUBLES |
| CARLOS MUNOZ | 2013 | MEN’S TENNIS | SECOND TEAM | SECOND DOUBLES |
| KEITH LEE | 2013 | MEN’S TENNIS | SECOND TEAM | FIRST SINGLES |
| RICHARD MILLS | 2013 | MEN’S TENNIS | SECOND TEAM | SIXTH SINGLES |
| SHAUNTIERAH DOUGLAS | 2013 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIELD ATHLETE OF THE MEET AWARD | |
| SHAUNTIERAH DOUGLAS | 2013 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST TEAM (NATIONAL CHAMPION) | JAVELIN |
| SHAUNTIERAH DOUGLAS | 2013 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST TEAM (NATIONAL CHAMPION) | 100M |
| SHAUNTIERAH DOUGLAS | 2013 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND TEAM (SECOND PLACE) | SHOT PUT |
| SHAUNTIERAH DOUGLAS | 2013 | WOMEN’S TRACK & IELD | COACHES ALL-AMERICAN (THIRD PLACE) | LONG JUMP |
| GINA PETTIGANO | 2013 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND TEAM | JAVELIN |
| YANIRI JIMENEZ | 2013 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | COACHES ALL-AMERICAN (THIRD PLACE) | SHOT PUT |
| MIKE AMARO | 2014 | WRESTLING | SEVENTH PLACE | 197LBS. |
| JEFF ROTTIGEN | 2013 | WRESTLING | EIGHTH PLACE | 133LBS. |
| LARRY BURROUGHS | 2013 | MEN’S BASKETBALL | THIRD TEAM | FORWARD |
| JONATHAN AISONI | 2012 | MEN’S SOCCER | SECOND TEAM | MIDFIELDER |
| FRANKIE BUENAFUENTE | 2011 | WRESTLING | THIRD PLACE | 149LBS. |
| JONATHAN AISONI | 2011 | MEN’S SOCCER | SECOND TEAM | MIDFIELDER |
| ASHLEY DEVANEY | 2011 | WOMEN’S BASKETBALL | SECOND TEAM | GUARD |
| ASMAR EDWARDS | 2011 | MEN’S BASKETBALL | THIRD TEAM | GUARD |
| THOMASZ DUGOZIMA | 2011 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST PLACE | JAVELIN |
| JULISSA DOUGLAS | 2010 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND TEAM | 400M IH |
| JULISSA DOUGLAS | 2010 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND TEAM | 100M HH |
| ELJIN BROWN | 2010 | MEN’S BASKETBALL | HONORABLE MENTION | FORWARD |
| RAMAZAN NANAYEV | 2010 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND PLACE | DECATHLON |
| TOMASZ DUGOZIMA | 2010 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND PLACE | JAVELIN |
| RICARDO GARCIA | 2008 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST PLACE | 400M |
| DERVAL THOMAS | 2008 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST PLACE | 100M |
| RICARDO GARCIA | 2008 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST PLACE | 400M |
| MARK EDWARDS | 2008 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST PLACE | 100M |
| KWAME BANAHENE | 2008 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST PLACE | 100M |
| HAROLD BLYDEN | 2008 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND PLACE | TRIPLE JUMP |
| HAROLD BLYDEN | 2008 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST PLACE | 100M |
| DERVAL THOMAS | 2008 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND PLACE | 100M |
| DERVAL THOMAS | 2008 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND PLACE | 200M |
| HAROLD BLYDEN | 2007 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST PLACE | TRIPLE JUMP |
| DERVAL THOMAS | 2007 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND PLACE | 100M |
| DERVAL THOMAS | 2007 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND PLACE | 200M |
| JAY PETTIFORD | 2006 | MEN’S BASKETBALL | HONORABLE MENTION | |
| MIKE MAZZENZIO | 2005 | WRESTLING | FIRST PLACE | 184LBS. |
| MIKE MAZZENZIO | 2004 | WRESTLING | SECOND PLACE | 184LBS. |
| THATCHA DACOSTA | 2004 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND PLACE | 200M |
| THATCHA DACOSTA | 2004 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST PLACE | TRIPLE JUMP |
| THATCHA DACOSTA | 2004 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST PLACE | LONG JUMP |
| VALBERT WYCHE | 2004 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND PLACE | SHOTPUT |
| RANDY BEDNARCZYK | 2004 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND PLACE | JAVELIN |
| ANGELIKA BARON | 2003 | WOMEN’S BASKEBALL | THIRD TEAM | |
| RANDY BEDNARCZYK | 2003 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST PLACE | JAVELIN |
| VALENTINA DILORETO | 2002 | WOMEN’S CROSS COUNTRY | THIRTEENTH PLACE | 21:33 |
| TED FITZPATRICK | 2002 | GOLF | FIRST TEAM | 302 |
| MIKE STANSFIELD | 2002 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | FIRST PLACE | JAVELIN |
| NICHOLAS CICCONE | 2002 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND PLACE | SHOT PUT |
| ARTHUR CULPPER | 2002 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND PLACE | 100M |
| JOE BURZINSKI | 2002 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND PLACE | 100M |
| OFORI KORMAN | 2002 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND PLACE | 100M |
| DENI DAKHEV | 2002 | MEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND PLACE | 100M |
| JANNY RIOS | 2001 | WOMEN’S CROSS COUNTRY | TENTH PLACE | 20:43.86 |
| RAY AIELLO | 2001 | GOLF | FIRST TEAM | 298 |
| TED FITZPATRICK | 2001 | GOLF | SECOND TEAM | 300 |
| RAU AIELLO | 2000 | GOLF | FIRST TEAM | 311 |
| ERIKA CZUJKO | 1999 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | WOMAN OF THE YEAR | |
| ERIKA CZUJKO | 1999 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | SECOND TEAM | SHOT PUT |
| SCOTT CLARK | 1998 | MEN’S BASKETBALL | FIRST TEAM | GUARD |
| ERIKA CZUJKO | 1998 | WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD | COACHES ALL AMERICAN | SHOT PUT |
| STEVEN KWON | 1995 | GOLF | FIRST TEAM | 233 |
| JASON BONO | 1995 | MEN’S SOCCER | FIRST TEAM | FORWARD |
| KLARA ZDEZKOVA | 1994 | WOMEN’S CROSS COUNTRY | TENTH PLACE | 22:16.7 |
| JASON BONO | 1994 | MEN’S SOCCER | SECOND TEAM | FORWARD |
| STEVEN KWON | 1994 | GOLF | FIRST TEAM | 224 |
| MATONDA FOSTER | 1993 | MEN’S BASKETBALL | FIRST TEAM | |
| JA BOEM SON | 1993 | GOLF | SECOND TEAM | 314 |
| CHAD LAPP | 1992 | GOLF | SECOND TEAM | 311 |
| ANN SOUREK | 1991 | WOMEN’S CROSS COUNTRY | FOURTH PLACE | 21:12.22 |
| SHARON RICHARDSON | 1991 | WOMEN’S CROSS COUNTRY | THIRTEENTH PLACE | 22:09.77 |
| DIANA DOVLETIAN | 1991 | WOMEN’S CROSS COUNTRY | TWENTY PLACE | 22:44.57 |
| ROBYN HEIM | 1988 | WOMEN’S CROSS COUNTRY | FIFTH PLACE | 18:46.21 |
| TERI GRIVAS | 1988 | WOMEN’S CROSS COUNTRY | NINTH PLACE | 18:57.68 |
| ROBYN HEIM | 1987 | WOMEN’S CROSS COUNTRY | FOURTH PLACE | 18:38.0 |
| MIRITZA ALVAREZ | 1987 | WOMEN’S CROSS COUNTRY | THIRTEENTH | 18:50.0 |
| BOBBY GAETA | 1985 | MEN’S BASKETBALL | THIRD TEAM (DIII) | GUARD |
| TIM DOHERTY | 1983 | WRESTLING | FIRST PLACE | 190LBS. |
| ROBERT YOUNG | 1982 | WRESTLING | THIRD PLACE | 158LBS. |
| CAMILLE BARONE | 1981 | WOMEN’S BASKETBALL | SECOND TEAM | |
| KAREN WILKES | 1980 | SOFTBALL | FIRST TEAM | PITCHER |
| THOMAS DEE | 1979 | GOLF | SECOND TEAM | 303 |
| CHRISTINE KOWALSKI | 1979 | WOMEN’S BASKETBALL | HONORABLE MENTION | |
| MATT PICCINICH | 1979 | MEN’S BASKETBALL | FIRST TEAM (DI) | |
| ARLENE OLCHESKI | 1979 | SOFTBALL | FIRST TEAM | OUTFIELD |
| THERESA VACCARELLO | 1976 | WOMEN’S CROSS COUNTRY | FIRST TEAM | 13:57.8 NOT MANDATORY 5K |
| CINDY MARCHESE | 1976 | WOMEN’S CROSS COUNTRY | FOURTH TEAM | 15:26 NOT MANDATORY |
| RICHARD MERIZALDE | 1972 | MEN’S SOCCER | SECOND TEAM | FORWARD |